Like most large cities in the U.S., D.C. has an over-abundance of average-quality Italian restaurants. Here are five diverse and great ones:
i Ricchi
Chef and owner Christianne Ricchi received the Insegna Del Ristorante Italiano from the President of Italy for establishing one of the best Italian restaurants in the world outside of Italy. Many of the signature rustic recipes at i Ricchi are from the family trattoria in the village of Cercina. The Tuscan menu is perfect for Mediterranean dieters. Grilled meats and baked entrees from the wood-burning grill are infused with a rich smoky flavor. Pasta and risottos are intentionally kept simple, using basic ingredients like perfect olive oil and vegetables, perhaps some homemade sausage. There is always grilled seafood and fowl on the menu, as well as freshly baked bread and homemade desserts. A Ricchi family favorite that is handmade daily is Tortelloni al Burro e Salvia, thinly rolled pasta around ricotta and spinach, with butter and fresh sage sauce.
Flowers and trailing greenery grace the spacious rooms, but the focal point is the wood burning hearth. Its warmth is complemented by terracotta floors, golden yellow walls, and rustic murals.
i Ricchi: 1220 19th Street NW; 202-835-0459; www.iricchi.net
Café Milano
Café Milano is best known as a happy late night hangout for beautiful young things in gorgeous clothes. Famous faces from Hollywood, New York, and Capitol Hill are a regular sight at dinnertime. During the day, business types and ladies-who-lunch fill the bright, sunny main dining room, where famed designer neckties decorate the walls. In good weather, a patio extends the scene out to the streets of Georgetown.
The food is straightforward elegant Italian. A good number of the pastas are homemade daily. Most dishes are light, pleasing to the calorie-conscious: think shrimp, asparagus and diced raw tomato with a splash of olive oil. For more substance, there’s pizza on the menu, as well as meat and seafood entrees, even grilled liver, accompanied by an onion stuffed with creamy risotto.
Kudos for high quality and flawless preparation go to Head Chef Fabio Salvatore, from Abruzzi, who knew food was his vocation from an early age. By 23, after his formal education and a stint in London, he moved to Washington for an executive chef position from which Café Milano’s savvy owner, Franco Nuschese, hired him away.
For an endorsement, you can’t get better than the Pope. The Vatican chose Cafe Milano to prepare Pope Benedict’s birthday meal at the Vatican Embassy when the pope visited DC in April 2008.
Café Milano: 202-333-6183; 3251 Prospect Street, NW; www.cafemilano.net
Tosca
Tosca can seem austere, with its pale grey and champagne palette, thick carpets, and heavy drapes. The designers knew what they were doing, however. This is a rare restaurant that is conducive to fine dining and conversation that doesn’t require raised voices.
The cuisine is inspired by Chef Massimo Fabbri’s native Tuscany. He blends fresh, locally grown, organic ingredients with must-have imports from purveyors in his home region. Outstanding dishes include ravioli stuffed with veal, prosciutto, and pistachio mortadella in a red-wine reduction; and sea bass (branzino) with balsamic vinegar sabayon. You can also request whole wheat pasta and simply grilled fish.
Small parties (up to
can dine at the Chef’s Table in Tosca’s kitchen, where Fabbri prepares a 7 to 9 course dinner of harmonious but exciting composition…an opera of sorts.
Tosca: 1112 F St. NW; 202-367-1990; www.toscadc.com
Potenza
The best pizza is usually the simplest, with traditional tomato sauce, top-of-the-line mozzarella and fresh basil. Potenza does pizza perfectly, and the breadsticks are amazing, too. This new Italian restaurant, bakery and wine shop caught on quickly with the downtown crowd. It seems to be full all the time despite less than glorious reviews, leading one to deduce that it has a great location and atmosphere, which it does, and you have to know what to order. Note the in-house bakery that prepares breads, pastas and desserts, the salumi counter and the raw bar. Let that information guide you.
In addition to the pizza, made in a gas-fired ceramic oven, focus on the cured meat sampler (the speck is made in-house) that comes with pickled vegetables; homemade –but unstuffed– pasta like the Maltagliati al Ragu di Pesce (seafood ragu) with a generous amount of seafood, heirloom tomatoes, and homemade basil pasta; pappardelle with hearty wild-boar ragu; and the fresh frutti di mare from the raw bar.
Executive chef Bryan Moscatello focuses on Southern Italian food, more accurately Italian-American food (“rigatoni and Sunday gravy”), but he makes it – and more — for grownups. The people that crowd into Potenza regularly know they can get a great meal in a friendly place without paying expense-account prices. They settle in, unfold the kitchen towel napkins, and prepare to dig in. It is possible to eat light here, but who would want to?
Potenza: 15th & H Street NW; 202-638-4444: www.potenzadc.com
Il Mulino
A special occasion restaurant with super-attentive and formally attired waiters, Il Mulino is reminiscent of the grand French restaurants that dominated high-end dining decades ago. This branch of the 30-year-old New York mecca is drawing the K Street lawyers and lobbyists, the business conference crowd, and prosperous couples. Wrought-iron chandeliers, tapestries and roses create an old-school ambience.
Many appetizers, on the house, come your way as soon as you sit down. A block of Parmesan might be followed by a basket of warm garlic bread, then bruschetta and fried zucchini. Save room! If you like veal, order the classics: ossobuco, saltimbocca, and picatta.The black truffle accented Capellini Il Mulino is irresistible with its wild mushrooms, pancetta and sweet peas in vodka cream sauce.
A note of interest: founding brothers Fernando and Gino Masci were born and raised in L’Aquila, the regional capital of Abruzzo, Italy, recovering from that terrible earthquake.
Il Mulino: 1110 Vermont Ave, NW; 202-293-1001; www.ilmulino.com